Today’s Star Tribune has an interesting column by Steve Berg (a member of Mount Olive, my home congregation in Minneapolis) about the occupation in Iraq. He presents that it is an easy question to ask–and one that needs to be asked: Why are we in Iraq?
(In case you missed the secret Downing Street memorandum, from U.S. President George Bush to U.K. Prime Minister Tony Blair, its contents all but laid out the roadmap that eight months prior to invasion, Bush had decided to invade Iraq, using all means necessary, including fabricating evidence. It’s published here, with commentary from the Times and Washington Post.)
Berg’s column creates a laundry list of possible reasons why we are in Iraq, ranging from the ridiculous to the extremely logical. All are downright frightening, and much of the rhetoric is not tongue-in-cheek, but what has been heard for the past four years on mainstream American and international media.
A. To remove the chemical, biological and possibly nuclear weapons that Saddam Hussein was about to hand over to the terrorists, posing an imminent threat to U.S. security.
A. To sever the link between the 9/11 terrorists and the Iraqi dictator.
A. To remove a brutal and despotic menace to stability in the Middle East.
A. To establish an Iraqi democracy as a model for change in the Islamic world.
A. To make the world safer.
A. To “finish the job” that Bush’s father started in the Gulf War, and to avenge Saddam’s apparent attempt to assassinate the elder Bush.
A. To secure Iraq’s oil supply, thus perpetuating America’s dependence on petroleum rather than launching a major drive toward energy independence.
A. To divert attention from the fact that we were unlikely to find Osama bin Laden and to concentrate instead on an enemy we could easily defeat on the open battlefield.
A. To attract terrorists from around the world to fight a consolidated war against the United States at a remote site, far from American soil.
A. To create a bigger, more telegenic war than the one in Afghanistan in order to appeal to the rising conservative tide at home — especially after 9/11 — and to win back the Senate for Republicans.
A. To slap down a dictator that the United States had helped in the past, especially in his war against Iran, but who then turned on his American benefactors.
A. To launch a latter-day crusade against Islam.
A. To do a favor for Israel.
A. To demonstrate that the United States is the world’s only superpower and that it’s willing to act in defiance of allies and apart from the United Nations.
A. None, some or all of the above.
What makes me the most sick throughout all of this is not the war itself, not the death and destruction that it has caused and not those who sit idly by and support the war, calling any who simply ask the question, “Why?” anti-American, unpatriotic, etc. For certain these things irritate me, make me sad and question the very fabric of humankind, but they don’t make me the most sick.
The fact that media coverage of the war in the American mainstream is spotty at best, missing at worst and abandons the principles of a free press makes me ill to my stomach. When other countries are reporting more about America than America is reporting about itself, other countries without a so-called free press that have more to lose legislatively than the American press, there is a problem. When journalists are so lazy and afraid of their news operation’s advertisers that they willingly accept being embedded with troops as opposed to independent research, there is a problem. When the American people no longer value a true, issues and information-based journalism market, there is a problem.
Great, so we have a problem. Two, in fact. We’re in a country with no exit strategy, and we’ve got a media that doesn’t work. Halfway around the world, people are dying in the hundreds daily. American service women and men are giving their lives for a war–which we are now learning more and more was not only unavoidable, founded on false pretenses but had no purpose from the beginning. Iraqi civilians, already trying to survive in brutal conditions, are now trying to stay alive just one more day in a war-torn country.
And here at home, we’re suffering the same death. The death of our intelligence and mental well-being.